When the dust settles

This Obama flap about Barack telling the truth about the ugly insecurities that are at the heart of what is wrong with the world and the politics meant to deal with the challenges of that world has got me thinking.

This whole godforesaken period of romanticism of the rules and force, like they solve more than they do, is reflective of a complex reality. On the one hand, it reflects all of those insecurities, which is why things have gotten so much worse. Because instead of challenging us to be better - which is what Obama has been doing with remarks like those he made about how many, especially uneducated, people tend "cling to guns and religion," when the going gets tough - so many people have chosen, instead to pander and coddle and genuflect and otherwise avoid the harder discussion which would involve challenging us to be better than our insecurities about life would suggest.

Our fears have driven us this period. That's what has fucked everything up. That's why I chunk it together the way I do. From about 2000/2001 to the current time, fear and insecurity has dominated the way that we have engaged in politics and the world. And it is reaped all sorts of bad consequences. And like the impulse that leads us to run with fear and insecurity as better guides than they are, we just keep rolling with those consequences until we can find the courage to face up to our failures.

Some people rarely or never find such courage. Many of those people are those who Barack was addressing. Neo-Nazis, Communists, radicals of all stripes, street thugs, serial killers. If you want a list of all of the people who fail to find the courage to face up to themselves, I'm sure it's quite long. And a lot of those folks, even when they don't situate themselves out in the extremes of contemporary life, are ordinary folks like you and I.

So, on the one hand, all this talk of rules and force is reflective of those fears and insecurities.

On the other hand, it is also a well-intentioned, if failed, effort to try to keep the world straight through all this mess.

The truth is that only our consciences can do that. Rules and force just complicate things, when they are used when other options are available and more effective. They always have. That's the nature of the bulk of our illiberal and repressive past. That's how it worked. We saw problems. We made rules. We used force. Things got fucked up. If you need a four sentence explanation of much of our tragic history, that will probably do. Our fears and insecurities drove us then, too. And they had consequence. And, luckily, then, as now, we had a handful of more honest people in the world - intellectuals, scholars, thinkers, compassionate and decent thinking folk all around made up the bulk of these people - who helped point us in better directions when our pride did not lead us to face up to our fuck ups.

Thank goodness for those folks, no matter how much we have always taken them for granted. Because this world would be in a much bigger mess if it weren't for their honesty. We'd be one big glob of bullshit and confusion. Which is why societies like Cuba and North Korea and Iran and Iraq and Syria and China and so many of the most repressive places in the world are such godawful messes. Because without the room for that kind of honesty - without that kind of freedom - there is no room to correct for the bullshit.

Nevertheless, all the talk about the rules and the rule of law, etc., is also, in part, a well-intentioned, if foolishly conceived, attempt to provide some kind of compass through all of the bullshit. But the truth is that the only compass that matters is a moral one, a compass of conscience and reason and judgment. And rules and force just make it all the more difficult to see through the bullshit, in great part because they help enhance it. Which is why so many indicators of well-being in the last 7-8 years have gotten worse and not better while we have rationalized them both.

If you have any doubts about that, go spend some time in places where rules and force are really taken seriously as governing philosophy, like any of those repressive countries I just named, and you will find a world of cynicism and ugliness with very little responsibility for the consequences they offer humanity.

There's really only one way forward. It's very much like any other regressive period in our past. You bullshit and bullshit all you want, but as things keep getting worse, people eventually start wanting better. They will today, too, just as always. It just takes some time to own up for the bullshit.

And when the dust settles, the only way forward is one of more freedom and more genuine, honest, and democratic engagement. Those who have studied liberal values know that deep down, even as many of them rationalize what they must know in their hearts is a bad direction.

And when we finally find our way, after fumbling around with this unfortunate path, we will not find a perfect world. Ever, really. What we will find is a world where more freedom and more genuine, honest, decent democratic engagement offers us better solutions, institututions, opportunities, etc., not perfect ones. Perfection and a perfect world doesn't exist. It's an illusion, and a dangerous one, at that, when it is used to rationalize all of the worst and most cynical gambles for power, greed, and a whole world full of ugliness. That's where the ulginess stems from, actually. That rationalization.

If the world isn't going to be fair, too many people rationalize, then I want to be on the side of the unfair stick that is to my advantage and to the disadvantage of others. It's an ugly gamble. It also happens to be one that doesn't pay off, much of the time, as it turns out. Honesty and virtue really do pay. Dishonesty really does end up fucking you in the end. I know from being on both sides of that stick, unfortunately. Most people have spent some time on both sides of that stick, unfortunately. Which should give us some compassion in a world where we all end up lost in the bullshit, some.

When the dust settles, we won't have a world that is completely fair. Even given a more honest commitment to our highest values, we will have a world that is more fair. There will never be a world that is perfectly fair. It just doesn't exist. We can make it more fair, with work. But this period has not been about making life more fair, really. This period has been about us rationalizing what shitheads we are.

Progress happens as we learn to own up for that tendency. And that is the only claim on progress that will ever be real. Everything else is a cheap shot meant to satiate our pettier natures that have just not learned to own up. Meaning, everything else is us avoiding the hard work that real progress necessitates. Which is fine. We're just never going to experience real progress without it. Avoid it all we want, I say. We're just not going anywhere until we own up.

That was the beauty of Barack's remarks. They reflected real progress. The need to be honest about ourselves. And to the extent that people resist that honesty, they can claim all kinds of things, but real progress isn't one of them.

A freer world will guarantee nothing. But that's the beauty of it. It places responsibility for our most important values and most important commitments - education, health care, retirement, employment and ownership, our democratic discussion, even national security, the most important priority that governments are responsible for - squarely in our laps. And if we don't take that responsibility, if we abdicate it, as we too often do today, then we are responsible for it, no excuses.

And that is the only way that we will make any real progress. Everything else is a well crafted illusion. And what always gives away illusions is that they never deliver.

It took 70 years for people to get figured out the illusion of Communism. I don't know how long it will take people to get this one figured out. At some level, I don't care. Because it's still an illusion, no matter how much its proponents prop it up. And eventually, whether it takes 70 years or 70 minutes, eventually people figure it out. It took thousands of years for humanity to get figured out that slavery was wrong. It took thousands of years for humanity to figure out that religion and unbridled force should not be the basis for governance and that reason and pragmatic, scientific, secular evaluations of ideas on their merits should be the basis for government. We eventually got it figured out. But it was wrong the whole time, no matter how much people pretended otherwise. This period is no different.

When the dust settles, we will choose freer lives. Because less free lives do not ever realize the illusion they promise. They just continue to sell the illusion. And when we do, that freedom will not solve all of our problems or make the world fair, out of the blue. We will need to make choices about how to solve our problems more effectively and how to make the world more fair. But it will be squarely up to us and noone else. And that will become clearer the more freedom we have and the more we take seriously that freedom and finding solutions that solve our problems on their merits and not based on some insecure, bitter, self-centered notion of how the world should be if it were perfect. It isn't and never will be. And facing that fact is probably the most important move towards progress that we could make.