Our greater humanity...
...or the irony of the politics of bullying each other toward responsibility...
I generally think if Rich Lowry as something of a weasel, honestly:):)...but this article in the most recent edition of the National Review is right on the money, I think...Rich is at his best, generally, when he is plucking the beams from the eyes of others, I think:):):)LOL:):):)...
Democrats and Iraq: The Gullible Party...
Rich basically argues that Democrats' constant argument that they were duped into voting for the war in Iraq and thus aren't responsible for their votes is nonsense, juvenile, and lacks real leadership...
And he's right...totally on...
It's been very disappointing to watch Democrats both embrace the victim mentality of the party that Bill Clinton did so much to try to leave behind...and to lack much serious leadership during this time from anyone, really, in Congress or even among Governors...I can't name one Democrat, right now, who seriously impresses me as a leader in the same way that Bill Clinton did...Barak Obama has potential...and there are plenty of non-politicians, of course, that I can think of with both leadership capacity and serious policy intellect...but none of them are stupid enough, is the short answer, to enter the American political ring with all of its pettiness, bitterness, nastiness, and thoughtlessness...
And Democrats, right now, just look like fools...working hard to get themselves off the hook for voting for the war...while giving very few if any constructive alternatives to the current situation...and playing up the politics of fear and victimization, domestically...it's been a sad spectacle, all around...
It's so ironic, isn't it?...
In an era claiming to be the an era of responsibility...
When every leader claims to have the recipe for more responsibility...
Which is, of course, to pressure and manipulate and otherwise bully their way in that direction...
None of them can take it...
Tell me something...
When was the last time you heard a major American politician or public leader -- Democrat or Republican -- say that they were sorry for something?...sincerely...not because they were pressured...out of attrition, or an insincere apology..but, sincerely...because they really believed that they had made a mistake and that they wanted to get on a better road?...
I believe that they feel sorry inside...to one degree or another...
But when was the last time that you heard John Kerry say, out loud...
"I'm sorry that I didn't research and discuss, openly, alternatives to the current situation in a way that would assist the President to develop a more workable policy for the war in Iraq"...
Or President Bush say...
"I'm sorry that I rushed to war with the arrogant belief that my opinion was the only one that mattered and the rest of the world -- the scholarly international policy community, in particular -- be damned"...
Or party leaders or members of Congress or the media say...
"We're sorry that we've promoted such an adversarial and generally pretty unconstructive discussion of different Iraq policy alternatives -- which is what a responsible Congress or media would do -- and instead framed every discussion point as attack, counter-attack, and as a function of the moral decency or depravity of various political players and short-term political advantage or disadvantage"...
When was the last time that you heard any of these folks who all claim to be the final arbriters of good and bad, right and wrong, wise and foolish...
When was the last time you heard any of them say, "I'm sorry"...
I say it...I say it all the time...when I think I've done something wrong...I probably say it more often than I should, sometimes, in an effort to cover all my bases and make sure that I've apologized if I think I even might have done something wrong, if I'm unsure...
When was the last time you heard any of these folks say, "I'm sorry"...or "I take responsibility"...
And yet...these are the same folks who claim to know just how to beat the country into shape...to get the American people to take responsibility for a whole range of issues that the country faces...
The war in Iraq and terrorism being our most important, right now, I believe...
When the evidence is so plain that bullying people into responsibility does not actually promote responsibility...
And that people generally promote bullying as a recourse the less they actually take responsibility, themselves...
Why would people so foolishly and stubbornly stick to the path that leads them persistently into damnation, I have to ask myself:):):)LOL:):):)...
A bunch of goddamn fools we are:):)...the human race:):):)...
Rich is right about Democrats...though he doesn't have a constructive alternative...or at least none of anything that I've read of Rich's suggests that he does...though I'm open to evidence to the contrary...
Why is it so damned hard for us to believe that if we are more decent and loving and honest...that the world would be a better place for it?...
Why do we spend so much useless time defending what shitheads we are?...and that it is the fact of our being shitheads that prevents more forward progress in getting people to take constructive responsibility for situations in a way that promotes more authentic collaboration towards a more genuinely constructive future?...
Why do we all spend so much time trying to defend our right to play bad cop?...and then none of us take responsibility when it gets us nowhere...
As Rich's quite accurate criticism of Democrats demonstrates is true among liberals, right now...
Because there's bad people in the world...
Because bad things happen to good people...
I swear to God that we are such fuckin' babies...
Aw...wook at da po witta baby...bad fings happen...and he just can't twust human nature:):):)LOL:):):)...
We are such fuckin' morons, sometimes:):):):)LOL:):):)...I swear to God:):):)LOL:):):)...
What is wrong with us that we just can't come to terms with the fact that bad shit happens...and that we're kind of shitheads, sometimes...but that doesn't mean that we have to give up on human nature...or people...or the world...or whatever stupid arguments we've made to rationalize what shitheads we are rather than giving it up...
Martin Luther King teaches love and forgiveness...and we practice harshness and bitterness...
Mohatma Ghandi teaches love and non-violence...a little naively, I have to admit...one account of Ghandi's life I've encountered argues that Ghandi thought non-violence would stop Hitler...pretty naive, I think...but non-violent resistance to British rule helped free India and inspire modern human and civil rights efforts...
The Buddha teaches to sit with pain...and to love and live with compassion...and to find peace...and, instead...we start commissions when things don't go exactly the way we want them to...and persistently assume that people are working in bad faith...
Jesus loves people...they shit on him, royally...because they're all kind of shitheads...
And we think that we should side with the crowd rather than, roughly -- though the question of Jesus' messianic claims can be set aside, for the moment -- with this very decent guy...because we just can't expect that people will behave better?...
Even though...in the centuries since that time...we've all gotten a lot better...and a lot nicer and more decent to each other...and a lot smarter...and a lot more able to function in this world, as a consequence...
Or maybe we should equivocate and "find a balance" between Jesus and the shitheads who crucified him?...or our current standard of more compassion and the shithead standard of Jesus' time?...
Or maybe we should embrace crucifixion even as we criticize Jesus being crucified...ignoring the fact that crucifixion gets used on an innocent, like Jesus, even as it is spared for guilty folks, like Barabbas, the thief and murderer who is released by Pontius Pilate in lieu of releasing Jesus...
Why do we all keep engaging in this stupid dance?...as if our efforts to bully our way to a better world...rather than building it...constructively...are really working?...
Why do we keep doing this?...
I mean the easy answer is...
Because we're petty...and small...and immature...and unable to face reality...no matter how much it stands before us...
Although...I think more likely...is that we are working in good faith...but just unwilling to face the reality staring us in the face...
Does anyone really believe that any punishment that they inflicted on Christ...no matter how awful the brutality...that they could have made him a better man with it?...
Does anyone really believe that?...
Does anyone really believe that Christ's captors and those responsible for inflicting punishment on him were better people than Christ?...
Does anyone really believe that Christ or anyone should make important decisions based on contrition -- meaning fear of punishment -- rather than attrition -- meaning a sincere belief that they've done something wrong?...
Do any Jews really believe that, if Jesus was not the messiah -- I don't believe he was, even as I recognize what a great man he was and what a transforming message he had for the world -- that he would or should have changed his heart or mind based on how much he was punished or brutalized?...
Does anyone really believe that?...
Because given the current political environment...
You would think that most people believe that...
That all that is needed to make the world better to get tougher on people...
That what Jesus needed was a good crucifixion...or a good beating, at least...or at least a some mildly bad treatment...to whip him in line...
And to see that he was mistaken...
Just like George Bush...
Just like John Kerry...
Just like Tom Delay...
Just like Howard Dean...
Just like Judith Miller...
Just like Matthew Cooper...
Just like Lewis Libby...
Just like Bill Clinton...
And just like a million other people...
In politics...journalism...sports...entertainment... and a million other places...
Where people need to be crucified...
Or at least pressured a little bit...
To do our bidding...
No matter whether our bidding is a good thing...or a bad thing...
And you know what the irony of it all is?...
That we do it to one another to persuade one another that we are right...
And that there is nothing that dissuades others more of our being right...than our attempts to hurt them and punish them or blame them...
Ironic, isn't it?...
You really think Pope Benedict arranging for the resignation of Father Thomas Reese at America magazine persuades Father Reese of anything?...
Do you really think that Pope Benedict can teach Father Reese to be a good man...and to condemn homosexuality...rather than allowing for an open debate and discussion on the matter within the Church?...
And more importantly...
Do you really think the Pope is right?...or the better man among the two?...
Why do we keep doing this?...
This dance of responsibility...
Everyone asserts that we want people to take it...
But noone takes it...
All the while pretending that this is the way to greater responsibility?...
Why do we keep doing this?...
Don't we care at all about building a world where people do take greater responsibility?...
Don't we care at all about actually being good...and not just looking good...not just playing our bit role in some self-righteous dance?...
Don't we care at all about actually making the world better?...and not just standing by our own self-righteous notions of it?...
As they beat Jesus with flesh-ripping weapons in the courtyard...and on the path to his own crucifixion...
I ball every time...
How do people do something like that...and never take responsibility for it?...
How do people sink to such brutality and depravity...and never see what monsters they become in the process?...
How do we all rationalize inhumanity...and never recognize it as such?...
And how in the world did the Romans and the Jewish leaders of the time...think they could do that...and that Jesus' message -- of love and compassion and forgiveness and decency and humanity -- would be wiped out by punishing him?...
Completely unaware...that the same man they were brutalizing...would capture the imaginations of Romans a century later?...
How naive...and stupid...and senselessly brute could they possibly be?...
Could we all possibly be?...
What was wrong with them?...
What is wrong with us?...
What is wrong is that the more we hurt others to get our way...
The more callous we become to it...and its consequences...for all of us...
The more aggressive and destructive we are...
The more detached we become from our humanity...
And from how aggressive and destructive we are...
Jesus is crucified...to prove that he's not the Messiah...
And his message of love...and decency...and compassion...and forgiveness...to love thy neighbor as thyself...to love thy enemy...to pluck the beams from our eyes before we pluck the splinters from the eyes of our neighbors...
All of this gets ignored...
So that non-Christians...can prove that he's not the Messiah...and to punish a blasphemer...
What is so hard...about learning the lesson...that our power to hurt...and to punish others...does not make us right...
That we can use force...in limited situations...in self-defense...to prevent future violence against us and others...and that always...as much as possible...we should use the least amount of force necessary...because no amount of force...persuades anyone that we are right...and its use often leads others to believe that we are wrong...even if we might be right...
And that our use of force...must...as much as possible...though possible is the real qualifier here...but...as much as possible...it must be used thoughtfully...
And that responsibility is not something that can be forced...it is something that must be learned...and internalized...from example...and experience...and study...
What is so hard about learning that lesson, I wonder?...
I'm not quite sure, any more...
If you haven't seen the Passion of Christ, yet, you definitely should...it's a much better movie than I gave it credit for, the first time around...my major criticism has been that it doesn't tell the story of Jesus' message, enough, I didn't think...though, on second viewing, it actually paints a pretty incredible contrast...between Jesus' message of love...even for one's enemies...and the brutality...of his persecutors and captors...
And then, as now...the debate is about who is responsible for such a tragedy...
Because then, as now...noone wants to take responsibility for it...
And so will be the fate of humanity...
Until we learn greater humanity...in the face of our stubborn inhumanity...
See the movie...if you haven't already...
Love,
Ben