Leadership is building commitment to doing the right thing
Poll: Support Drops for Afghanistan War
Something is amiss, these days, in America and the world.
And America's discussion about the war in Afghanistan should be the big red flag for everyone that this is so.
The Afghanistan war, for those who were never fully convinced - I include myself, here, when the war was initially declared - really was and is the war of self-defense. This is in contrast to the Iraq war, which was a worthy war of choice, I believe, with a far-less-than-worthy effort to persuade others of that fact.
After Al Queda attacked on September 11th, the means of capturing or killing remaining fighters, likely to strike again if not contained or killed, was limited by the their ability to find save haven. They had one in the mountains of eastern Afghanistan (and western Pakistan) with no recourse to capture or kill them given a Taliban government that was sympathetic to the cause of Al Queda and not likely willing, in any uncertain terms, to cooperate with the United States.
Absent a U.S. invasion, Afghanistan not only had one of the more brutal and oppressive regimes, over its own people whom had no say over the matter, and towards Muslim people, for those concerned about the fate of Islam under liberal or illiberal governents, in the world. More immediately threatening to U.S. interests, it was a safe haven for Al Queda fighters operating and planning future attacks on the United States and other targets with impunity.
In other words, without invading Afghanistan, the likelihood of Al Queda remaining on the offensive and attacking the United States again was very high. By invading, Al Queda played mouse to our cat and laid low in hiding (and we had a better chance of capturing Bin Laden and the lot) and a terribly ugly and brutal regime gets taken out, in the process, and Afghanis could elect a government of their choosing democratically. Just as we take for granted in the good ol' U.S. of A. as we debate the very issue.
Now, that is the argument that should have been made and debated in 2001, and was, in part, when America first invaded Afghanistan.
And the fact that we didn't discuss and debate this invasion or the invasion in Iraq nearly thoroughly, respectfully, open-heartedly, and open-mindedly enough - and with more focus on doing good than looking good - has everything to do with why the domestic politics is such a mess, on both this war and the war in Iraq and most issues America faces, right now.
So lots of fucking up in this war, the war in Iraq, and all around. And mostly, contrary to popular opinion, not around the military strategy - where America has always had overwhelming force - but around the political matters - in how we understand and engage the people issues, more honestly - and our failure to have an honest and respectful enough discussion and debate about all the people matters that matter.
And in a way where everyone did exactly what everyone is so loathe to do today.
To admit the only and most important honest thing they could possibly admit about anything of any import.
That they may not have all the answers. That they could be wrong. And that, thus, there was plenty to explore, with a genuinely open mind and heart, to arrive at better decisions.
All of this is true. And all of this has created an enormous clusterfuck in Afghanistan. And Iraq. And on most issues that America faces right now. Largely because we've all be acting like assholes and acting like acting like assholes has no consequences when it so clearly has.
So, now, that's where we're at, today.
Now, 9 years later, with nearly 10 years of emotional and upsetting debates about both these wars and any number of issues that matter to people, and with a long war with lots of Americans dying, people have grown war weary.
Understandable. Especially when a lot of folks are not completely clear on the stakes in this war. And many of them may just disagree with me, no matter how clear I am that the stakes are too high to just pull out and supposedly cut our losses.
What's not understandable is all of that meaning that America pulls out of the one situation where self-defense was and still is (as far as I know, Osama Bin Laden is still at large) the real legitimate reason to go to war. And to do so knowing that doing so will leave Afghanis to the devices of those brutal thugs who used to rule their country, in league with the very brutal thugs who killed our people and were the reason for us being there, in the first place, and will do so, again, as soon as they have the inkling they can get away with it.
What's not understandable, in other words, is quitting. Because it's hard.
All the while, pretending what tough little badasses we are to the rest of the world.
It's fuckin' weak, is what it is.
It's fuckin' pathetic.
And it is exactly what America has become in the early 21st century the more we march down this dark path we've been on.
America wants to prove how tough she is.
Stick it out and do the right thing.
And stop making excuses for why we don't wanna.
Or why the fact that we don't wanna somehow means that the people who do want to stick it out need to follow suit. All to suit your ego. And pride. And whatever damn fool impulse drives you, these days.
In other words, perhaps Afghanistan can be a genuine restart.
An opportunity for America to do what she has been failing to do for the last 10 years.
To lead.
And leadership meaning building commitment to doing the right thing.
Patiently. Honestly. The way real, sustainable commitment of any kind is built.
Even when all the popular winds point otherwise.
I don't care how weary we feel.
We went here for the right reasons. And we're fighting there, now, for the right reasons.
And if we leave, Afghanis go back to a brutal, barbaric existence.
All so we could pretend how tough we were.
But not really be tough when it counted.
Meaning, resigning ourselves to being a nation of whining little pussies.
All the while crowing about how fuckin' tough we are.
And then bailing, when the going gets tough.
Leadership is calling out that bullshit for what it is.
And building commitment to something genuinely better.
And we are all welcome to follow anything else that we please.
But pretending like doing so is really our best, or toughest, or most thoughtful selves is really just bullshit. No matter how you try to spin that one.
And if America leaves Afghanistan. They deserve to be known for the fuckin' whiny, tough-talkin' little pussies they turned out to be.
And no amount of talking our way out of that one will make anything different from what it really is.
America is not a country of whiny, tough-talkin' little pussies.
Not for long, that is.
Because we have what it takes to be better than all that bullshit.
And we're gonna stick it out in Afghanistan and demonstrate that's true. And not just talk it.
Doubt that? Watch, motherfucker.
And you know why, captain?
Because nothing else would be worthy of the name American.
And, in my book, at least. That still means something.
